A good example of how the STATUS QUO in Kenya makes decisions.

Since 1963 consecutive regimes follow the same script, fuata nyayo so to say. The script goes: “the ordinary citizen is an idiot. He or she is to be TOLD but never LISTENED to!”

KUAMBIWA bila KWUSKILIZWA!

The STATUS QUO will spend millions to build markets force people into those markets, the traders run away since there are no customers coming there, the project fails and the STATUS QUO or GOVT. OF THE DAY will then blame the trader for the failure.

The hawker or trader then retorts , “si mngetwuuliza tuwambie kwanza, tu suggest , twuskilizane, mahali mzuri na mjenge jinsi tutatoshea sisi wote bila mvurugano! Sasa mmejenga hata hatujui hizo sheds zinapatianwa aje ama kwa nani, hatutoshei na customer hawezi kuja hio njia yote! Ni mbali sana na customer!”

Hata Kibaki alianguka mtihani kabisa na Muthurwa though he was a good leader.

The same script is repeated in hospitals that are built hundreds of km. away from residents… wamama wanajifungulia kwa njia… or schools like this one here below where some officials come in and dump millions worth of electronic training equipment and then disappear . They never bothered to even find out where the students will be sleeping. They never bothered to even seat down with the community and understand what courses the youths there would like to pertake; or even what courses guarantee employment within the community after their studies. Yaani what courses will impact the community the most.

Na vijana wakikosa kazi baadaye wanaambiwa ni shida yao! Na mshalipa school fees. All our universities practically fall in these quagmire. They just wake up and announce tomorrow we will start teaching law.

When you don’t involve people directly they cannot OWN or LOVE or APPRECIATE a public project.

I once saw a documentary of a small town in Japan where two past mayors had been completely unable to build a community center due to the huge costs involved. The community center would include small shops and a mall, a movie theatre, yoga classes, spas etc. Something to regenerate the community and bring in much needed cash. The third mayor in line brought in the whole community and for several months they deliberated together. Wanakosana, wanatukanana, wanapigana hadi mwishowe wanaskizana and they even shake hands. It’s not a pretty process. The mayor was called a thug many a times.

But he then realized that a sizeable majority of the residents in that town were on wheels and didn’t walk.

Majority of the residents were old or ageing or newly wedded young couples with toddlers in prams. The old had walkers canes or motorized wheelchairs. So the whole community center could just be built as a single story building with ramps and no stairs and save a lot of money.

The whole community chipped in with ideas and the project was actually completed at a fraction of the original cost with numerous cost effective changes and the place was a roaring success. The guy got re-elected.

I’ve also seen an Arabian emir, a king moving around the villages in village bazaars and he talks to subjects as if they are his own relatives. By the time that emir leaves that village they even know what the guy discussed with Trump the previous week. They know how much oil was sold in the first quarter of the year. They know which mosque will get a facelift first. The emir even knows there’s an outbreak of diarrhea in a certain quarter of the town… yaani involved leadership. Hata mkifanya project it can’t fail because you are on the same page. No hidden hands. No suspicions. Hata hatembei na bodyguards wengi and he eats with the citizens.

I have also seen Kagame a dictator talking to his subjects in round tables about ordinary stuff. Listening to ideas, answering questions. Very heated debates over common problems. Na wanatatua.

Ukikuja Kenya. The equivalent of such bazaars na mwuitwe mkutano msomewe speech kama watoto! No ideas gathered. Ni kuambiwa tu. I have seen hawkers in the markets launched recently wamezipokea lakini ni shingo upande. Choo hazitoshi. Choo za walemavu hakuna. The roofs are too low… kwani how hard is it to just involve these people in that project from the start?

Ndio STATUS QUO waibe vizuri bila kujulikana. With community involvement kushikwa ni rahisi sana. Because the community will first ask, “budget inatoshana aje Mheshimiwa Waiguru?”

[SIZE=7]Multi-million shilling facilities idle as youth snub craft courses[/SIZE]
By Jacinta Mutura
Published: Aug 10th 2018 at 23:01, Updated: August 10th 2018 at 23:01

https://www.standardmedia.co.ke/images/friday/pmhydburmfq6chslkx95b6deeefd905d.jpgJohn Warui attends to engineering equipment at a Laikipia East Technical and Vocational College lab. The multi-million shilling equipment is lying idle for lack of students. [Jacinta Mutura, Standard]
A walk on the hallways of Laikipia East Technical and Vocational College evokes feelings of isolation.

This ambitious institution that should be brimming with life has instead become a pale shadow of what it was meant to be.

Its halls that are supposed to be noisy due to clanking of machinery are silent.

Comfortable seats placed next to each control dashboard to enhance a relaxed environment for students during practical lessons for electrical engineering classes are a pointer to what should actually be happening.

Gathering dust

A demonstration desk is the focal point of the room with a new projector, covered computer monitor and a projection whiteboard suspended on the wall for lectures.

Advertisement
Your opinion is valuable. Take this quick survey to help us improve the website and content
The impressive arrangement of the apparatus in the spacious workroom has not been interrupted seven months after the facility was opened.

The image of the lab replicates in other three workrooms at the facility which from outside appears to have much to offer but it just mesmerises since it is yet to serve its purpose.

Some machines are still in cartons in the facility’s stores, others are accumulating dust in the lecture rooms.

John Warui, a store keeper, spends much of his day keeping watch and wiping the dust off the multi-million equipment meant for electrical and electronic engineering.

“This is what I do every day. I report in the morning to check on the equipment and make rounds to ensure they are safe.

"It is unfortunate that this facility has everything students would require but none have enrolled,” Warui says.

Equipment worth Sh160 million lie idle at the facility as students shun technical and craft courses. The vocational college can take in 500 students.

A similar establishment lies at Posta in Mouwarak in Laikipia North. The school is fully equipped and Sh140 million was pumped in for renovation.

Prospective students

A Sh150 million equipment for training in mechanical engineering lies idle at the institution as there are no students.

Although the two facilities are located about 20 metres from the road, prospective students identified their location as a key constraints leading to failure on enrollments.

Despite millions pumped into the centres, accommodation for students was not considered. The Government has no plans to build hostels.

The one in Mouwarak is located on the Rumuruti-Maralal highway while the one in Laikipia East is located at Marina on Nyeri-Nyahururu Highway, where residential buildings are a major challenge.

Courses the institutions should be offering include electrical and electronic engineering, mechanical engineering, building technology, cooperative management and information communication technology (ICT), all at artisan, craft and diploma levels.

Concerned with the situation, Governor Ndiritu Muriithi has rolled out plans to market the institutions in an effort to put into use the gigantic facilities.

The county boss intends to utilise the August holidays to lure youths from across the county through a campaign dubbed Rapid Improvement Programme in Education (RIPE).

The month-long campaign is targeting to enroll 1,000 students to the two institutes.

“We agreed with school heads to use more social strategies to attract students.

"They should make announcement in churches, family meetings, social gatherings and hold sessions with school leavers to enlighten and encourage them to enroll,” said Muriithi.

Community meetings have been arranged in Mkogodo West and Mkogodo East areas to market the courses in the villages.

Form-four leavers have been asked to carry their result slips to the meetings for enrollment.

Speaking at a Maasai cultural event in Arjijo, elites from the community pledged to scout for at least 100 youngsters from the region and see them join the institutions.

Idle youth

Governor Murithi has urged parents to encourage their children to enrol for these clases instead of idling around.

He said skills in plumbing, carpentry, welding and mechanics are in high demand.

Lack of hostels, the governor said, is an opportunity for investors to build residential houses for students.

Simon Ngatia, the principal of Laikipia East Technical College, attributed the near nil enrollment to stigmatisation of technical institutions as places for those who fail to attain qualifications to join university.

“The workshops and laboratories are fully equipped for training but the institutes are crying for students.

Technical institutes are not meant for Standard Eight leavers but anyone who wants to pursue the courses offered,” Murithi said.

To encourage enrollment, the national Government has introduced a Sh30,000 capitation for every needy student joining technical institutes, and reduced the annual fee to Sh56,420.

Paying the remaining Sh26,420 has also been made easy as those eligible for loans can get as much as Sh40,000 from the Higher Education Loan Board (HELB).

Needy students could also get bursaries from the board.

Meanwhile, statistics from the county reveal shocking details on transition gaps from primary to secondary education levels.

Laikipia County Statistical Abstract indicates that in 2017, only 590 students enrolled in the 10 technical training institutes (formerly called youth polytechnics) despite each of them being capable of holding at least 400.

Among the enrolled 590 students, 443 were male. Only 147 females were admitted in the same year.

Long read but one thing is that when the government is performing executive functions, unless stated by law otherwise, deliberating with the public only wastes time. The government has the data and resources to make key decisions sometimes without the public’s input.

So much bile and as usual a lot of assumptions. That aside, let me ask. Are you suggesting there should be a top-down approach where those in government come down to the community? Is there any chance for a multi-faceted approach with a bottom-up approach incorporated? How were the equipment acquired?

Kenyan technocrats and planning are like water and oil.

What is your definition of good leadership?

So goes the argument: Citizen participation wastes time!

“You guys elected us to make the decisions for you as per the law! What are you guys paying us as lawmakers and as your leaders for? You saw how citizen participation at the Bomas draft brought headaches!”

Na ni hao hao politicians ndio walileta head ache pale Bomas sio raiya…

And I mean where have all these executive decisions lead us eventually, Mr. Simiyu?

How is Kenya today? We are so over represented with leadership yet even simple basics can’t get done.

I posit here that lack of openness with the public is actually what breeds corruption.

The number 1 source of corruption in Kenya is lack of openness. Ours is not an open society.

We are lead by being told and not being engaged.

Ruto will stand somewhere on a podium and declare, “Tunajenga hii barabara kuanzia kesho!”

And the conditioned sheep will rejoice and what not. And the STATUS QUO will even be very defensive if the media starts poking their nose in there asking about financial figures.

Baadaye… ndio hizo scandals! Mara, wanarudia ati this time ni dual carriageway…

In an open society projects are driven by NEED, PRIORITY, and CITIZEN PARTICIPATION, just like in a well run house. Democracy should not stop at elected leaders, the next phase is serious public engagement. Waseme kama hata ni town hall meetings like in Trumpistan.

So today the Kenyan STATUS QUO in a list ditch effort hopelessly declares that they are opening internet portals mtoe mawazo.

Hawker hata anajua portal ni nini?!

Muthurwa isn’t a failure my friend.
It’s a thriving market which over the years has it’s own customers separate from the ones served on the streets by hawkers.
Initially, the hawkers who had been allocated the stalls complained that their customers hadn’t followed them there, sold the stalls to other parties and moved back to the streets.
It’s the latter group who bought the stalls that is currently reaping the benefits.

700 million down the proverbial drain…

[SIZE=7]MUTHURWA A FAILURE, ADMITS COUNTY HALL[/SIZE]
[SIZE=5]Posted on Jan 25, 20141528 Views[/SIZE]

https://nairobinews.nation.co.ke/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/muthurwa-523x350.jpgCurrently, Muthurwa is a crowded mess of matatus jostling for a place to park, dusty and muddy roads, burst sewers, pickpockets and lack of clean water for the hawkers. PHOTO| FILEBy ALLAN OLINGO
Muthurwa market is a failed project, County Hall has admitted. Change of use by the traders is to blame, said County Executive in charge of Trade, Industrialisation, Co-operative Development and Tourism, Anna Othoro.
“Even when Muthurwa was handed over, it wasn’t in a state to be used fully as a retail market. It was supposed to be a hawker market where they would walk in, place their wares and sell. They have, however, turned it into a retail market with permanent structures which were not designed with it,” Othoro said.
When the market was being designed, its plan included a 24-hour market with basic facilities such as water, rest rooms, lighting, a hospital, a police station, multistorey stalls, a banking hall and administration offices.
Though its construction did not include all the plans, the Sh700 million market, opened in 2007 by the then president Mwai Kibaki, was hailed as a trendsetter by many.
Currently, Muthurwa is a crowded mess of matatus jostling for a place to park, dusty and muddy roads, burst sewers, pickpockets and lack of clean water for the hawkers, which contribute to the chaos that has become synonymous with the market.
Othoro, however, says the county government has major plans to rehabilitate the trading centre as a retail market for its current use to become sustainable.
“Once the hawkers turned it into a retail market, we had to go back to the drawing board and I am pleased to say we have approached the World Bank to fund its rehabilitation. We are now at the design stage. Once the architects complete this, we will have a time line for the market’s rehabilitation,” she says.
Othoro admitted that the revenue County Hall was currently collecting from the market could not even meet its maintenance costs.
That is why, she said, the market is falling apart. “Whatever the traders pay to use this market is too minimal to ensure the basic market standards are met,” she said.
It cannot pay for its maintenance; leave alone its rehabilitation. We hope that in the next two years, the situation shall have changed,” she says.

Muthurwa actually failed within the first year of operation:

https://www.standardmedia.co.ke/article/1144014583/muthurwa-market-dream-has-failed

[SIZE=6]Others… @Simiyu22 if they just bothered to consult the final user, now millions/billions are down the drain.[/SIZE]

https://www.nation.co.ke/news/Shame-of-projects-worth-millions-that-lie-in-ruins/1056-4589822-24lvgs/index.html

[SIZE=7]Shame of projects worth millions that lie in ruins[/SIZE]

FRIDAY JUNE 1 2018

https://www.nation.co.ke/image/view/-/4589824/highRes/1992455/-/maxw/600/-/2q68i8/-/PROJECTS+PIX.jpg
A section of Karatina market, which is under construction. The facility has been under construction since 2010 and has consumed over Sh370 million. PHOTO| FILE |NATION MEDIA GROUP
In Summary
[ul]
[li]In Kwale, Maji Moto springs was identified as a major tourist attraction centre but the project was abandoned despite millions spent to spruce it up. [/li][li]The Magombani open market in Lunga Sub-County has been abandoned.[/li][li]In Nyeri, six out of the eight markets are not in operation.[/li][li]In Murang’a, a Sh30 million market constructed opposite Maragua police station is also idle.[/li][li]In Kisii, most markets constructed by the National government are idle.[/li][/ul]
https://www.nation.co.ke/image/view/-/3508610/medRes/1333041/-/i793rg/-/LOGO.jpg[B]By NATION TEAM[/B]
More by this Author
Scores of projects across the country that cost the taxpayer billions of shillings are lying idle.
Most of the projects, mainly markets in urban areas, were constructed with funds from the Economic Stimulus Programme in the second term of President Mwai Kibaki.
The programme was launched in July 2009 with an initial funding of Sh22 billion.
Its objectives were to spur economic growth and create employment by building markets and other infrastructural facilities. It followed the post-election chaos of 2007 that depressed economic growth.
Other projects were funded under the Ministry of Agriculture’s Smallholder Horticulture Marketing Programme (Shomap) and Constituency Development Funds.
But today, most of these projects have been boycotted for a number of reasons.
Related Content
[ul]
[li]MCAs to quiz officials on stalled road projects[/li][li]Graft and poor workmanship blamed for stalling projects[/li][li]Regime change puts completion of projects in danger[/li][li]Coast, Western, Nyanza gained the least in new roads projects[/li][/ul]
Where markets are unoccupied, [SIZE=5]traders say[/SIZE] they are in [SIZE=5]bad locations and there are also disagreements on how much counties should charge them to do business there[/SIZE]; because of bad workmanship, the roofs of the markets are also leaking or their walls have cracked scaring the traders. At the Coast, many such projects have stalled.

DRAINAGE SYSTEMS

They include drainage systems, markets, tourists’ attraction centres, football pitches as well as roads.
Residents claimed some of the buildings were hurriedly built and their walls collapsed.
The Changamwe market in Mombasa, the Maji Moto Springs in Lunga sub-county whose perimeter wall collapsed and Diani drainage system are .
Changamwe market was initiated by the then area MP Ramadhan Kajembe. It is now home to thousands of crows.
The Mombasa county government has allocated Sh20 million in the 2018/19 budget to rehabilitate Magongo and the Changamwe markets.
In Kwale, Maji Moto springs was identified as a major tourist attraction centre but the project was abandoned despite millions spent to spruce it up.
The Magombani open market in Lunga Sub-County has been abandoned.

PUBLIC PARTICIPATION

Other projects that were completed but are not in use include Nyumba Sita market stall in Msambweni Sub-County.
Residents claimed [SIZE=7][COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)]public participation in the project was poor because they had opposed construction in an isolated place.[/SIZE]

The Kwale town bus park is also complete but is not operational. When contacted, County Secretary Martin Mwaro declined to comment.
In Lamu, some residents [COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)][SIZE=6]said they were not aware of any project constructed by the ESP funds[/SIZE][SIZE=6].[/SIZE]
Many of those interviewed by the Nation blamed local leaders for failing to ensure the money was used for the intended purpose.
Mr Paul Mwiruri of Hindi in Lamu West said [SIZE=5][COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)]no leader had come out to explain the issue.[/SIZE]
[COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)][SIZE=6]“We only heard[/SIZE] the government had set aside money to improve agriculture and jua kali sector among others. We haven’t so far seen any tangible projects in Lamu which were established as a result of the money. Our leaders can explain better,” said Mr Mwiruri.

ECONOMIC STIMULUS PACKAGE

Mrs Halima Bwanamkuu of Witu said she was aware Witu was among the places intended to benefit from the Economic Stimulus Package.
She said she was not aware of any single project in the area constructed using the money.
Governor Fahim Twaha said Lamu was among the areas that received the Economic Stimulus Package but was quick to say nothing much was done by the then municipality.
“I remember we proposed various projects to be undertaken in Witu, Hindi and Mpeketoni. I am yet to make follow up and know exactly about the progress of the projects. It’s almost ten years now and I am not informed about the projects’ current status,” said Mr Twaha.
In Nyeri, six out of the eight markets are not in operation.
The markets are Kamakwa, Mweiga, Karatina, Kiandu, Kiaruhiu and Othaya. They were all completed in 2014 except Karatina whose construction is still ongoing. Othaya and Kamakwa markets, both of which cost Sh60 million, are yet to be operational. Traders still operate in open streets.

NEW MARKET

[COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)][SIZE=6]In Othaya, traders have refused to occupy the new market.[/SIZE]
Ms Mary Nyawira, a businesswoman in the town, [COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)][SIZE=7]said the people were not consulted when the project was implemented.[/SIZE]
[SIZE=7][COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)]The market, she said, is in a wrong location.[/SIZE]

[COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)][SIZE=7]“We felt relocating to that place will lead to declined sales. It would have been constructed within the town or near a place with high population and movement of people,” said Ms Nyawira.[/SIZE]
[SIZE=7][/SIZE]
[SIZE=7]She advised the county government to relocate the bus terminus from the town to a field adjacent to the market.[/SIZE]
The market is near the yet to be opened Sh1 billion-Othaya District Hospital, which has also been under construction for at least eight years now.
A women’s leader and trader, Ms Josephine Gathogo, said the market was a good idea and if well managed would lead to economic growth.
“The current market is congested and many traders are operating on the roadside. If the county government makes good plans and organises operations, there will be no complaints,” said Ms Gathogo.

DEMOLISH TEMPORARY STRUCTURES

In Kamakwa market, Richard Kagera, a trader said they were forced to demolish their temporary structures to create space for construction of the modern market in 2010 but up to now the market has not been opened.
In Meru, weeds and insects are reclaiming seven horticulture markets.
Disagreement over their status before handing over to the county government as well as disputes on management have turned the facilities that cost close to Sh250 million into white elephants.
Out of the eight facilities, only one is being used for sale and storage of bananas.
At Thimangiri in North Imenti, the Sh27 million centre equipped with a ripening chamber and a cold room was used for a short while before a dispute over management scuttled operations.
Thuura Vision Group, which was managing the facility, accuses the county government of demanding too much tax from the centre.
“The county officials wanted to take control of the market. They were charging Sh20 per banana bunch. Farmers were not making any money from selling at the facility. Some of us have since uprooted the bananas while others sell to brokers,” Mr George Mutua, the group’s chairman said.
At Kithaku in Imenti Central, potato farmers who were to reap from the modern market are nowhere to be seen.

POOR ROADS

The floor is covered in dust while cobwebs fight for space in 158 lockers, some of which are still locked after they were allocated to farmers in 2015.
Despite gobbling up Sh36 million, only a handful of farmers operate from the spacious Kithaku Horticulture market.
Mr Silas Mutai, the chairman of Kithaku smallholder farmers group that initiated the project, blames poor roads for the collapse of the market.
In Tharaka Nithi, a Sh10 million fresh produce market at Kajiunduthi in Maara constituency has been idle for the last eight years.
The market has a capacity to accommodate 30 fresh produce traders, but villagers say it is only used as a meeting place by women’s groups.
Maara Sub County Agricultural officer Mwirigi Kirera told the Nation the market has never been used because it was built at a place without an existing centre.
[SIZE=6][COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)] He said he was the area agricultural officer during construction[/SIZE][COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)] [SIZE=7]but he was never consulted.[/SIZE]
[SIZE=6]“I have never known who constructed or funded this project and even after its completion, it was never handed over to the local agricultural officers,” said Mr Kirera.[/SIZE]

ABANDON MARKET

Ms Lucy Kaari, a resident, said the centre [SIZE=5][COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)]could be useful if it was constructed at nearby Marima market centre where there are people to buy produce.[/SIZE]
In Murang’a, a Sh30 million market constructed opposite Maragua police station is also idle.
According to Mr Kamande Kariuki, a trader, they boycotted the market because it was too far from Maragua town.
“It is unfortunate the national government and the then MP Elias Mbau[COLOR=rgb(184, 49, 47)] [SIZE=5]constructed the market away from our clients.[/SIZE] [SIZE=7]We had no choice but to abandon the market and continue operating here at Maragua town,” Mr Kariuki said.[/SIZE]
In Kisii, most markets constructed by the National government are idle. Six markets are yet to be opened and traders said they had waited in vain to be allocated spaces.
Kisii County Secretary Patrick Lumumba, however, said the markets may be opened in the coming two weeks.

AWAITING FORMAL NOD

“Many of the markets were not finished and this has caused delay in operationalising them,” Mr Lumumba told the Nation.
At Kiamokama, in Masaba South, residents said they were told the markets could be opened ‘soon’.
“Six years later, we are still waiting to be allocated spaces. We have been patiently selling outside with hope that we will soon get spaces. With these heavy rains things are not any better for us, “said Gesare Onkubo, a vegetable dealer.
The situation is similar at Riombongi, and Masimba where traders said they are still awaiting a formal nod to access the markets.

Reports by Fadhili Fredrick, Winnie Atieno, Kalume Kazungu, Magati Obebo, Joseph Wangui, Alex Njeru, David Muchui and Ndung’u Gachane

Lol

@patco. Your arguments are all over the place. Public participation does not stop corruption. The reason these projects are stalled is due to corruption. Corruption is stalled by various institutions performing their duties diligently and impeccably.

umewahi sikia these terms: user-centered design and Usability testing? You have to involve your target users at every step of your creation ama when you launch utaumia

:smiley:

sasa unataka ku argue hata vitu obvious?! Vitu common sense. If you are not being watched closely you tend to steal. Na ukiangaliwa kwa utaratibu hautaiba. You will behave yourself. Simple.

Leta hio research inasema public participation does not stop corruption. Bring examples to support that madness.